Platinum price trend remains sluggish; is it still worth investing? In-depth analysis and decision guide

Question

Platinum, as a rare variety among precious metals, has performed far below expectations in recent years. After reaching a historical high of $2,200 per ounce in 2008, platinum prices have remained in a prolonged state of fluctuation. Currently, platinum prices continue to be under pressure, and many investors are hesitant: Is it still a good time to invest in platinum? This article will analyze from multiple dimensions including historical trends, supply and demand status, and investment mechanisms.

Platinum Price Trends: From Peak to Trough Over 20 Years

To understand platinum’s current predicament, we must review its historical trajectory.

The most glorious moment occurred on the eve of the 2008 financial crisis. At that time, South African mines faced severe supply shortages due to labor disputes, car manufacturers had strong demand for platinum, and international investors viewed it as a hedge against inflation and economic uncertainty. Platinum prices once soared to $2,200/oz.

However, after the crisis erupted, platinum experienced a sharp plunge. By November 2008, prices had halved to $774. This period revealed the fundamental difference between platinum and gold—gold is seen as the ultimate safe-haven asset, while platinum is primarily an industrial commodity, with prices driven entirely by supply and industrial demand.

The historical low of $360/oz was recorded in 1998, reflecting the impact of the Asian financial crisis. During the global recession, demand in automotive, aerospace, and other industrial sectors collapsed, excess supply flooded the market, and prices plummeted.

Between 2000 and 2008, platinum prices experienced a significant upward cycle, but from 2011 to 2015, they declined again, mainly due to slowing global economy and reduced Chinese demand.

The recent volatility began in 2019. Eskom, South Africa’s state power company, faced mounting debt, leading from intermittent power outages at the start of the year to continuous blackouts lasting days or months by year-end, causing platinum mining equipment to halt. The COVID-19 pandemic worsened this situation—South Africa implemented a three-week nationwide lockdown, halting all mining activities; simultaneously, China’s auto production sharply declined. Platinum faced dual pressures from its origin and import markets.

From March 2020 to early 2021, as the global economy restarted, auto manufacturing rebounded, and central banks adopted easing policies, platinum prices surged again. But this recovery was short-lived.

Mid-2021 to mid-2022, chip shortages and global logistics disruptions hampered the auto industry. After mines in South Africa and Russia resumed, market oversupply emerged, and platinum prices declined again.

At the end of 2022 to mid-2023, the market held high hopes for increased platinum demand following China’s reopening, and prices briefly rose. But reality disappointed—China’s economic recovery was much weaker than expected.

Since 2023, platinum prices have been trapped in a range-bound oscillation. On one hand, South Africa, accounting for 70% of global output, continues to face power shortages, strikes, and mine closures, leading to insufficient capacity; on the other hand, the Federal Reserve’s more hawkish policies than expected have raised recession fears, dampening industrial metal demand. The combination of sluggish industry and supply chaos has kept platinum prices under continuous pressure.

Why Did Platinum Fall? Understanding the Supply and Demand Logic

Unlike gold, whose price is mainly driven by investment sentiment, platinum’s price fluctuations are entirely determined by supply and industrial demand.

Supply side: Monopoly of South Africa and Russia

Global platinum production is extremely scarce—2018 global gold output was 3,332 tons, while platinum output was only 165 tons. More critically, platinum mining is monopolized by South Africa and Russia, with South Africa accounting for 70% of global production. This highly concentrated supply structure means that political or economic fluctuations in a single region can cause significant global market volatility.

South Africa’s power crisis is a typical example. The national power company cannot maintain stable supply, leading to mine shutdowns, directly reducing global platinum supply. Similar labor disputes and exchange rate fluctuations can also trigger chain reactions affecting prices.

Demand side: Automotive industry as the main driver

Platinum’s industrial applications are far more extensive than gold and silver. The automotive industry is key—both platinum and palladium are used in catalytic converters for cars, buses, and trucks to reduce emissions. Additionally, platinum is used in turbines, medical devices, computer chips, and the petroleum industry.

However, platinum’s application in automobiles is mainly concentrated in diesel vehicle catalytic converters. As global emission standards tighten, gasoline vehicles are increasingly using palladium instead of platinum. This means the primary application domain of platinum is shrinking.

Global macroeconomic factors also influence demand. When the economy is booming, car sales increase, boosting industrial demand for platinum and raising prices; during recessions, automakers cut production, demand shrinks, and prices fall. The automotive shutdown during COVID-19 is a typical example.

Cumulative macro factors

US real interest rates, the US dollar index, and gold prices also indirectly impact platinum prices. More importantly, market expectations of recession directly depress all industrial metals, including platinum. The Fed’s hawkish stance fuels recession fears, acting as an invisible hand suppressing platinum prices.

Is Investing in Platinum Still Viable? Risks and Opportunities Coexist

Faced with continuous declines in platinum prices, investors need to make rational judgments.

Investment prerequisites: Deep understanding of fundamentals

Platinum investors tend to be more professional than gold investors. They understand that technical analysis and fundamental research are key drivers of prices, with high risk awareness. If you decide to invest in platinum, you should first have a clear understanding of the following questions:

Are you optimistic about the medium-term prospects of the automotive industry? The popularity of new energy vehicles may change future demand for platinum, but this process could take 5-10 years.
Can you withstand high volatility? Platinum prices are far more volatile than gold, requiring strong psychological resilience.
What is your judgment on South Africa’s political and energy situation? This directly affects global platinum supply.

Multiple strategies to cope with platinum’s decline

First option: Short selling — If you believe platinum will continue to fall, you can profit from the decline by buying put options, selling platinum futures, or buying inverse ETFs.

Second option: Hold or increase holdings — This is a more aggressive strategy. If you are confident in platinum’s long-term outlook and believe prices will rebound, you can choose to hold or even add at low levels. But this requires in-depth understanding of market fundamentals, not just emotional speculation.

Third option: Diversify investments — A classic risk mitigation approach. If your investments are overly concentrated in platinum, consider allocating funds to stocks, bonds, or other commodities to hedge against single-asset downturns.

Fourth option: Wait and see — During periods of high uncertainty, waiting for clearer signals is also a wise choice.

Platinum, Palladium, Gold: Who Is More Worth Investing In?

The investment logic of these three precious metals is entirely different.

Gold: The ultimate safe-haven asset

Gold is currently the most popular investment precious metal. It is not an industrial commodity but a store of value, with prices mainly driven by investment sentiment. When the economy is unstable, geopolitical tensions escalate, or inflation is high, investors rush to buy gold, pushing up its price. Gold is negatively correlated with stocks—when the economy is good, investors sell gold to buy stocks; during downturns, the opposite occurs.

Gold’s advantage is its strong safe-haven attribute and relatively low volatility; its disadvantage is limited growth potential.

Palladium: The darling of industrial metals

Palladium and platinum are both key materials for automotive catalysts, but palladium is mainly used in gasoline vehicles. As global emission standards tighten and consumers shift from diesel to gasoline cars, palladium demand has surged.

In September 2017, palladium prices surpassed platinum for the first time in 16 years. Over more than a decade, palladium prices kept rising, reaching a record high of $2,754/oz in late February 2020. But then, in mid-March, it fell to $1,743, a 36% drop.

Palladium supply is extremely scarce—annual output accounts for less than 0.5% of gold’s, and inventories on hand are continuously declining. However, analysts believe that the high palladium prices are prompting automakers to develop substitutes. Chemical giants like BASF have announced development of new catalysts that replace palladium with platinum in gasoline vehicles. If this technology becomes widespread, it could alter the entire market’s supply and demand landscape.

Platinum: At a crossroads

Platinum currently faces an awkward situation. It does not have the ultimate safe-haven properties of gold, nor the booming demand of palladium. Its main application is in diesel vehicles, a market that is shrinking.

Unless two scenarios occur—either the automotive industry’s development of alternative technologies for platinum fails, or the global shift to electric vehicles experiences a major reversal—platinum’s outlook remains uncertain. Currently, the probability of either scenario is considered low.

Comprehensive Overview of Platinum Investment Methods

If you decide to invest in platinum, you need to understand the characteristics of various trading options.

1. Spot platinum

You can directly purchase and own physical platinum. The advantage is direct ownership of tangible assets; the disadvantages include paying sales tax, insurance, and storage fees, which often exceed the costs associated with gold. Due to higher difficulty and costs in casting, platinum’s premiums are higher than gold’s. Additionally, liquidity may be an issue when liquidating.

2. Platinum ETF index funds

Investing via platinum ETFs does not require holding physical platinum, only paying low management fees. The advantages are low investment costs, good liquidity, and ease of trading; the disadvantages are that prices are affected by market and index performance, which can lead to larger fluctuations.

3. Platinum futures

Futures are standardized exchange contracts allowing investors to participate with a small margin in large-scale trading (leverage). The advantage is the ability to profit from both rising and falling prices; the disadvantage is that it requires strong market knowledge and risk management skills, making it unsuitable for novice investors.

4. Platinum Contracts for Difference (CFD)

CFD is an agreement between investors and brokers to profit from the difference between opening and closing prices. Unlike physical platinum, CFD investors do not need to handle delivery or storage.

CFD’s advantages include the ability to go long or short, providing two-way trading; typically no commission, only spreads; and the ability to leverage with smaller margins for larger trades. The risks are high leverage, potential for amplified losses, and strict margin requirements.

Core Principles of Platinum Trading

Regardless of the investment method chosen, the following principles must be adhered to.

Follow the trend, avoid contrarian trading — Platinum trading is more complex than other commodities. Investors should go long in upward waves and short in downward waves. Unless there are strong reversal signals, avoid trading against the trend.

Set stop-loss and take-profit points — This is fundamental to capital management. Enter at predetermined levels, and exit promptly within controlled losses if the market moves unfavorably. Success or failure is common; the key is to learn from experience and reflection.

Trade with small positions, diversify risk — Due to the active nature of metals markets and platinum’s high volatility, it’s recommended to start with small positions to test the trend, avoiding heavy positions. Market unpredictability requires diversified allocations to prevent large single losses.

Final Reflection: Who Is Suitable for Platinum Investment?

Platinum investment is relatively new and not the first choice for traditional investors. Only investors meeting the following conditions should consider entering:

Have a deep understanding of industrial demand and the automotive industry
Able to tolerate higher price fluctuations than gold
Possess strong technical analysis skills
Willing to spend time researching South Africa’s energy situation and global economic fundamentals
Have a high risk tolerance

For ordinary investors, the current prolonged downturn in platinum prices is a period worth paying attention to but requiring caution. If you have unique insights into platinum’s long-term supply and demand fundamentals, low prices may present opportunities; but if your understanding of fundamentals is limited, it’s better to deepen research before making decisions. In the capital markets, knowledge and discipline often outweigh luck.

View Original